This task had students work through math problems, that were
presented to them in a different form then they usually see. Students were
given this worksheet and instructed to first count the number of dots on the
left side of the domino and place that number under the part square. Then
students were told to count the dots on the right side of the domino and place
that number on the right side of the part square. Finally students were told to
add the parts 1 and 2 together to get the total, or add up the number of dots
on the domino. I would say this assignment is not higher level thinking,
because this task is mostly memorizing. This task does not allow students to
make the problem their own, or incorporating it into real world problems. The
task is simply asking the students to add numbers together. The only thing the
dominoes are doing for the students is providing them with a visual reference. This
student told me he counted the dots on the left then continued counting the
number of dots on the right, which would be your total.
Questions:
1.
Does the use of the dominoes provide students
with a better understanding of how an addition problem works?
2.
Does the domino really help the students?
3.
Does the students understand that the use of
dominos is just another way of making an addition problem?
I would try to find the answer to these questions by
interviewing a wide range of students and ask them a couple of questions. I
could ask them an addition problem without the visual aid of the domino, and
then after they answered the questions, I would present them the same addition
problem with the aid of the dominos. This would show me if they depend heavily
on the picture or if they could see it’s a simple addition problem. If the
student’s can’t answer the addition problem without the aid of the dominoes
then this shows me they depend too much on the visual aid, and maybe they don’t
mentally now the addition problem. These little interviews with the students
will allow me to see what some students know and what others may not still
understand.
These are excellent questions. And I agree that interviewing students and asking for their reasoning as they solved the task would indeed be the most productive way of trying to understand what students got out of this activity.
ReplyDelete